Is There a Life After Death? A Philosophical Approach

No one can definitively answer if life after death exists, but delving into philosophy inspires a deeply meaningful, authentic life.

Dec 9, 2024By Viktoriya Sus, MA Philosophy

is there life after death philosophy

 

Is there life after death? Humans have been intrigued by this question for centuries. While science can try to answer it based on evidence alone, philosophy takes a different approach, delving into metaphysics. Some thinkers have argued that death marks the end of consciousness itself. Others have suggested that although our individual minds may cease to exist, somehow or other, we might carry on being part of something larger than ourselves. In this article, we will take the philosophical route. So, what are famous philosophers saying about life after death?

 

Plato: The Immortality of the Soul

michelangelo last judgement painting
The Last Judgement, Michelangelo, 1536-1541. Source: Wikimedia Commons

 

Plato presents an interesting viewpoint on what happens after we die—suggesting the soul’s journey stretches far beyond earthly life. Picture a place where everything is perfect and pure, somewhere our souls long to return to once they’ve finished with our bodies: this is Plato’s world of forms.

 

In his dialogue Phaedo, Plato takes us through Socrates’ last moments as if we’re right there with him. The philosopher faces death in a calm and fascinating way, talking about whether or not our souls live on.

 

Using vivid examples, Socrates makes it clear he thinks dying isn’t something bad that happens to you at the end of your life—like punishment for a crime you didn’t commit. Instead, he says (to put it simply) that it’s like being released from prison because now your soul can return to where it belongs.

Get the latest articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up to our Free Weekly Newsletter

 

Plato’s philosophy revolutionizes our perception of life itself. It calls on us to consider how both living and dying fit into a larger scheme. Instead of simply ceasing to exist once we die, Plato suggests that our souls might wake up to something even more real—and spectacular—than anything we’ve experienced before.

 

For Plato, death isn’t an occasion for dread; it’s a hopeful step towards a higher existence. This view asks us to think differently about individual deaths and consider the sweep of human mortality: Can looking beyond our lives as mortals help reveal truths about goodness and beauty that never fade?

 

Aristotle: The Soul as the Form of the Body

eugène delacroix barque of dante painting
The Barque of Dante, Eugène Delacroix, 1822. Source: Louvre

 

Contrary to his teacher Plato, Aristotle had a practical view of life after death. Rather than believing that the soul moves from one realm into another at its demise like an independent voyager, he considered the soul to be bound up with the physical body.

 

In his book De Anima (On the Soul), which examines living things’ essence and their functions, Aristotle argues that if you think about what happens to a soul after it leaves its “home” (the body) behind, then you haven’t grasped what souls are for or what they do. They give bodies vital activities—they make them living things.

 

To put it another way, according to Aristotle’s belief system​, anything that has a function in form cannot exist separate from matter. You wouldn’t speak of a song having somewhere else to go when it’s not being sung by anybody—because songs don’t exist apart from singers! Nor does choreography have meaning without dancers.

 

As a result, Aristotle moves away from considering what might happen after we die to concentrate on how we can make the best of our lives right now. Instead of seeing existence as a preparation for an unknown next stage, he wants us to achieve eudaimonia—usually translated as “flourishing”—by exercising reason and practicing virtue in this life.

 

Aristotle’s ideas mean that we should embrace the present moment. We should try to live ethically and with purpose because that way, we will be fulfilling our highest potential. Because who knows whether there is any further stage beyond death, and if so, what it may be like?

 

Epicurus: Death is Nothing to Us

gustav klimt death and life painting
The Death and Life, Gustav Klimt, 1910-15. Source: Leopold Museum

 

Epicurus, an advocate for leading a tranquil life, had a refreshingly simple take on what happens after we die: don’t worry about it. According to Epicurus, everything we experience—whether good things like joy or bad things like pain—comes from our ability to feel them.

 

But once we’re dead, we can’t feel anything at all because that capacity has gone away. So there’s nothing scary about being dead; it’s not like there’s something unpleasant happening to you, Epicurus would say.

 

Think about the perfect summer day when you’re enjoying yourself so much that you forget all your worries in the warm sun or while eating ice cream with friends. In moments like these, which Epicurus thought people should aim for as much as possible (as long as they didn’t cause pain to others), he might argue that death shouldn’t preoccupy us.

 

Epicurus taught that we should seek a life of simple pleasures, friendship, and peace of mind—not fraught hours pondering what happens after death or worrying about not existing. Why care about an afterlife when it’s unknowable? Or stress out over nonexistence after we die?

 

Instead, Epicurus said to enjoy the feelings and experiences life provides—creating a happy existence for ourselves that leaves no room for dread. In this way, we can live well and also take away death’s ability to scare us because if it can’t harm our enjoyment of life itself, then what is there to be afraid of?

 

The Buddhist Perspective: Reincarnation and Nirvana

pieter bruegel the elder triumph of death painting
The Triumph of Death, Pieter Bruegel the Elder, 1562-63. Source: Museo del Prado

 

In Buddhism, life after death is understood in terms of reincarnation and Nirvana, which presents a religious and cyclical idea of life. Instead of thinking about life as a one-off journey, Buddhism teaches that individuals are born again and again once they die—this endless cycle is called samsara.

 

Central to samsara is karma, the moral law of cause and effect. Simply put, what you do affects what happens when you are reborn. If your actions are good, you’ll return in a better form next time; if they’re bad, you can expect something less pleasant.

 

To grasp this concept better, picture autumn leaves falling into a river. They drift along for ages before finally breaking down. Then, bits of them help nourish new plants. The leaf’s journey mirrors the Buddhist cycle of samsara: each life presents an opportunity for personal growth and purification with the aim (goal) of reaching—or at least getting closer to—ultimate happiness: Nirvana.

 

For example, imagine someone accumulating good karma through living mindfully and compassionately. This person isn’t just trying to get a better position in their next life—they’re actually on track to reach Nirvana, a state of profound peace and liberation from all suffering. To get there, they’ll need to practice ethical conduct, meditation, and wisdom (which can help purify their mind enough to break free from samsara’s cycle of rebirth).

 

In Buddhism, we see a different take on life after death. Instead of aiming for some final destination, it’s more about continuing along a path that leads to moral and spiritual growth—ultimately culminating in release from the whole business of dying and being born again.

 

St. Thomas Aquinas: Christian Theology of the Afterlife

hieronymus bosch seven deathly sins painting
Table of the Seven Deadly Sins, Hieronymus Bosch, 1505-10. Source: Museo del Prado

 

St. Thomas Aquinas introduced a Christian perspective on life after death that combines faith with reason. In his important theological work Summa Theologica, Aquinas explored subjects such as the soul’s nature, how God judges us, and what will happen to people once they have died if their soul is found separate from their body.

 

Aquinas claims that each individual soul is immortal; God creates it directly, and it cannot die when the person does. After death, each soul will undergo divine judgment.

 

To understand this better, imagine a courtroom—but one where God’s laws rather than human ones determine what is right and wrong. In this court, everything about you—every choice you made (good or bad), every kind or cruel thing you did—is completely open for inspection by an all-knowing Judge: God himself.

 

Those souls whose lives demonstrated love, kindness (according to the commandments of God), fidelity—as well as compassion for others—will find themselves welcomed into heaven.

 

On the flip side, those who don’t follow God’s laws and turn their backs on His love will face something else entirely: damnation. According to Aquinas, hell is what you deserve if your life is stained by unrepentant sin—a state of being separated from God and everything good for all eternity. It’s a sharp reminder of how important our moral choices are.

 

Aquinas offers an ordered view of what happens after we die—one where our souls continue on and our actions from earthly life still matter morally. By combining Christian teaching and ideas from philosophy, Aquinas encourages people to live virtuous lives because they believe it’s right while holding out for divine justice that brings eternal rest.

 

Søren Kierkegaard: Existential Perspectives on Death and the Afterlife

william adolphe bouguereau dante and virgil painting
Dante and Virgil in Hell, William-Adolphe Bouguereau, 1850. Source: Wikimedia Commons

 

Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard takes a fascinating approach to death and the afterlife in his existentialist philosophy. Unlike many before him, Kierkegaard does not present a systematic theological or philosophical system. Instead, he focuses on what it means for individuals to exist—with freedom and responsibility.

 

According to Kierkegaard, death causes us to think deeply because at that point, we will be confronted with how authentic our lives have been. Kierkegaard doesn’t say outright what happens when we die.

 

Instead, he challenges us to consider both the certainty of death and the unknowns afterward. Rather than avoid thinking about or feeling anxious about this situation, he suggests embracing thoughts and feelings as natural parts of life, which can provide people with direction and purpose.

 

Imagine an artist who knows they will die soon, creating art not to be remembered but because it is a true expression of themselves. Kierkegaard would say this shows how someone can live passionately, even when aware of death’s presence.

 

Kierkegaard doesn’t use the idea of death or an afterlife to comfort us or tell us what to do next. Instead, he leaves us with a question: How do we live so that we always become who we really are? And how do we make these choices fully aware that we only have limited time left—and that nobody else can choose for us?

 

So, Is There a Life After Death?

john everett millais ophelia painting
Ophelia, Sir John Everett Millais, 1851-52. Source: TATE

 

The mystery surrounding what happens after we die has fascinated people for centuries and led to many theories. In his writings, Plato describes how the soul can strive for perfection in another realm. Aristotle, however, believed that when we die, our souls die too.

 

Epicurus was one of several ancient philosophers who argued that we should not fear death because once it arrives, there will be no sensations—good or bad. Buddhism introduced the idea of cyclical rebirth until reaching Nirvana (a transcendent state free from suffering), while Thomas Aquinas outlined a system where one’s life is judged, and one either goes to heaven or hell.

 

All these perspectives offer potentially helpful ways to think about post-death existence, but none can be proven. They are available as food for thought rather than gospel truth. We don’t know if there is life after death. But thinking hard about this subject could still be important. It could affect how we live our lives!

Author Image

By Viktoriya SusMA PhilosophyViktoriya is a writer from L’viv, Ukraine. She has knowledge about the main thinkers. In her free time, she loves to read books on philosophy and analyze whether ancient philosophical thought is relevant today. Besides writing, she loves traveling, learning new languages, and visiting museums.